With Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula, Loren D. Estleman, who by the way now has an excellent reputation as a contemporary mystery novelist, fashioned a traditional (i.e., ordinary) Holmes pastiche, despite the dramatic inclusion of the king of Counts. Whether this new story idea was originally Estleman's or his agent's, or even his publisher's, who can say?
Watson performs his scribe role admirably, but at the end of the adventure, Holmes indicates that publishing such a tale would be inadvisable, as long as there were surviving participants. Thus Watson sequestered his notes on the subject and paid them little mind for a number of years, but there came a day when Holmes sent a message, the gist of which was, "Write it up and publish it now." Holmes' dearest friend obliged (but then, Holmes changed his mind and Watson's record of that adventure remained unpublished until the ms. fell into into the hands of Estleman resulting in the manuscript finally coming to life.)
Riding his success in this new-for-him style of writing, Estleman embarked on a similar thriller, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Holmes. It too enjoyed some success, but then the author-cum-"editor" put his deerstalker, magnifying glass, and blue pencil in the bottom drawer of his bedroom press and returned to the maze-like mysteries of our modern world; though an occasional short story from Watson by way of Estleman would later be found in the occasional anthology.
Years later, the Quality Book Club issued a nice trade paperback that contained both novels...er...memoirs from Dr. Watson's hand. It's a handsome, sturdy volume. It's fun to have both of these novels bound together, as there is so much that binds them together.
Sunday, February 18, 2018
Sunday, February 4, 2018
Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula (1978) "edited" by Loren D. Estleman—Post 5a
Before I begin my comments on Sherlock
Holmes vs. Dracula, I want to apologize. I had no sooner started this “Ruminations” book review blog in
early December than I suffered two separate health emergencies. I posted my
last review on December 27, 2018 and today is February 4, which means I lost 39 days
while recovering. I also came to the understanding that it’s unrealistic for me
to read one Sherlock Holmes book a week and post a review. Therefore, I will
post new reviews only as I am able, or somewhat irregularly. Thank you for your
continued interest.
So far in this column I've reviewed books that are historically important and/or not necessarily traditional Holmes. I view Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula by Loren D. Estleman to be untraditional—at least in its own day, having special significance today for at least three reasons:(1) The American paperback publisher of SHvD in 1978-1979 was Penguin Books, a company with big international connections. It appears that Penguin had a mystery line, if advertisements in the back pages for Georges Simenon, Graham Greene, Geoffrey Household, and Lionel Davidson are any indication. Nevertheless, the company's editorial focus for decades seemed to be mainly on public domain classics, for example Edgar Allan Poe, Herman Melville, Mark Twain, Jack London, and Wilkie Collins.
Then in 1979, Penguin published the American mass-market paperback of Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula. This no doubt raised a few eyebrows for the reasons that (a) it was probably the company's first foray (if not THE first, then amongst the first) into uncharted new popular fiction by a contemporary author, (b) nevertheless, its design staff seemed to have been intransient regarding modernizing the company's decades-old cover design. Thus SHvD was released appearing no different from the company's titles for Poe, James, Twaine, London, ad infinitum. Still this may have been deliberate, as I will show in the second reason.
(2) All the above notwithstanding, it cannot be denied that once Penguin committed to publishing SHvD, they provided at least one giant-sized wink to both players of the Holmes "Great Game" as well as to ordinary Sherlock Holmes fans who happened to be observant. Frankly this wink I find immensely pleasurable!
As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words. But a bit of preface is advisable first. Ordinarily the very first page of a book is called the "half title" page which merely presents the book title without reference to the author. Hardcover books and trade paperbacks usually comply to this standard; however, the publishers of most mass-market paperbacks, long ago eschewed this practice, preferring to place countless glowing critics' reviews on the first pages. Penguin books has also consistently ignored common practice by—more staidly—dedicating the first page of its books, a practice continuing into the present, to thumbnail authors' biographical information.
Thus, for example, the first page of a book by M.R. James would display a note on James' life condensed down to 50 or 150 words. For instance, here is the real first page from a James' book:
As I said, co-oping the "half title" to display functional yet scholarly mini-biographies, has been a Penguin practice for decades. Thus when the time came to use in a functional manner that sacrosanct first "half title" page for its new acquisition, Sherlock Holmes vs Dracula, by John H, Watson as edited by Loren Estleman, Penguin's editors, rather unstaid-like, placed their tongues firmly in their cheeks, and produced the classic mini-biographies that follow:
(3) Further, it may well be that SHvD may be the first post-Seven-Percent pastiche to centrally feature another writer's fictional characters—if not the first, then certainly amongst the first, and, in any case, proving to be far more influential than not.
To be continued and concluded in Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula by Loren D. Estleman—Post 5b.
Formal notice: All images and quotations used in this blog and its individual posts are used either with permissions from the copyright holders or through exercise of the doctrine of Fair Use as described in US copyright law. If any true copyright holder (whether person(s) or organization) wishes an image or quotation to be removed from this blog and/or its individual posts, please send a note with a clear request and explanation to eely84232@mypacks.net and your request will be complied with as quickly as practical.
Monday, November 27, 2017
The Lost Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Ken Greenwald (1989) - Post 4
by Ken Greenwald, based on the original
radio plays
by Denis Green and Anthony Boucher.
In the 1930s and 40s, before television, individuals and
families clustered around the radio much as they do with the TV these days.
They listened intently to the plethora of variety shows, the news, serious
drama, and adventures. The radio networks were filled with radio plays, many based
on properties that existed long before radio became popular, shows like SUPERMAN
and THE LONE RANGER. One such show was THE NEW ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES
starring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce. In 1946, Rathbone left the show,
passing the baton to perhaps half a dozen actors. The show remained popular for
four more years.
Regarding why I consider this to be a landmark Sherlockian
book, here is the backstory: Rathbone and Bruce were in the first 220 half-hour
radio episodes of THE NEW ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES, which aired from 1939
to 1950. Apparently audio recordings of the whole series existed and were
available for 40-odd years—except 1945. The recordings for all of 1945 were considered
lost. But in the 1980s, a vintage radio club that included Ken Greenwald
located the lost recordings. They produced at least one LP with the recordings,
and then somebody had the idea to write short stories based on the recovered
1945 shows. Greenwald took up the challenge and by 1988 he brought into the
world 13 new Sherlock Holmes short stories in a book titled THE LOST ADVENTURES
OF SHERLOCK HOLMES.
Greenwald was obviously tuned into the Holmes pastiche
culture of that era, which is something I conclude because THE SEVEN-PER-CENT
SOLUTION started the tsunami of Holmes pastiches only about a decade earlier,
assuming Greenwald began writing in the early or mid-1980s. For example, the
book includes an excellent framing device at the start and a clever Introduction
by Dr. John H. Watson explaining how the fortunes of this, his last volume of
Holmes stories, was less than stellar due to all of England preparing for The
Great War (aka World War I) in 1914. The few copies that were printed
eventually faded away and the entire book was forgotten.
To my taste, all 13 stories are well-crafted and enjoyable. In
his Foreword, Greenwald admits having trepidations about his writing style,
concerned that the stories may seem “off key” because Doyle/Watson was not the
true author. In my view the stories, which are told from Watson’s point of
view, which is only right and proper, succeed in wonderfully evoking Dr. Watson page
after page.
The titles of the stories are “The Adventure of the Second
Generation,” “The April Fools’ Adventure,” “The Case of the Amateur Mendicants,”
“The Adventure of the Out-of-Date Murder,” “The Case of Demon Barber,” “Murder
Beyond the Mountains,” “The Case
of the Uneasy Easy Chair,” “The Case of the Baconian Cipher,” “The Adventure of
a Headless Monk,” “The Case of the
Camberwell Poisoners,” “The Adventure of the Iron Box,” “The Case of the Girl
with the Gazelle,” and “The Adventure of the Notorious Canary Trainer.”
Sunday, November 19, 2017
Murder By Decree by Robert Weverka (1979) Post 3
novelization
by Robert Weverka,
screenplay
by John Hopkins
I
think it’s fairly safe to say that the single historical event that is played
out most often, again and again and again, by Sherlock Holmes pastiche writers
is nothing less than the Whitechapel murders of 1888—Jack the Ripper. Doing a
quick check online, I’ve found 12 that fall into this category. I am certain I
could find others as well if I wanted to devote more time to the project, but I
‘m pretty sure that listing these 12 goes a long way to prove my point.
• A Study in Terror, novelization by Ellery Queen and Paul W. Fairman, screenplay by Derek Ford and Donald Ford (1966)
• A Study in Terror, novelization by Ellery Queen and Paul W. Fairman, screenplay by Derek Ford and Donald Ford (1966)
• Murder By Decree, novelization by Robert
Weverka, screenplay by John Hopkins (1979)
• An East Wind Coming by Arthur Byron
Cover (1979)
• The Last Sherlock Holmes Story by
Michael Dibdin (1987)
• The Whitechapel Horrors by Edward B.
Hanna (1993)
• Dust and Shadow: An Account of the Ripper
Killings by Dr. John H. Watson by Lyndsay Faye (2009)
• Whitechapel: The Final Stand of Sherlock
Holmes by Bernard Schaffer (2011)
• Sherlock Holmes and the Whitechapel Vampire
by Dean Turnbloom (2012)
• Jack The Ripper: Newly Discovered Adventures
of Sherlock Holmes by Holy Ghost Writer (2014)
• Sherlock Holmes and the Autumn of Terror
by Randy Williams (2016)
• The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes:
The Ripper Legacy by David Stuart Davies (2016)
• Sherlock Holmes and the Whitechapel Murders:
An Account of the Matter, by John Watson M.D. by Mark Sohn (2017)
It
appears that the first two “novels” within this category began as films with
the screenplay “novelized” to be ready to sell when the film was released. My
attention here is focused on the second novelization, Murder By Decree, which followed A Study in Terror by 13 years.
I
have selected the novelization of Murder
By Decree as the third book of my new blog—“Ruminations on Sherlockian
Books”—for the dual reason that first, in my opinion, it is an outstanding novelization—one
of the best I’ve read (at all times maintaining the conceit or illusion that I
am actually in the presence of the doctor and the consulting detective, which
is no easy task.) Also, if one thinks of all these books as pre- and post-The Seven-Per-Cent Solution, as far as I
can tell, Murder By Decree appears to
be the first Ripper/Holmes mash up after 1974’s The Seven-Per-Cent Solution, being released in April 1979, while An East Wind Coming was released in
November 1979. I view Murder By Decree
as important because it was written soon enough after Nicholas Meyer’s The Seven-Per-Cent Solution that it can
legitimately be considered the first Holmes/Ripper book to be part of the
ensuing flood of knock-offs that followed Meyer’s hit novel.
The
credited novelization author is Robert Weverka; it turns out he novelized a
great many films and TV series during the 1970s, including the Academy Award
winning The Sting, The Circle of Iron, The Waltons, and The Magic of
Lassie. Of course, the movie and the book don't match perfectly. There are many scenes that have changed during the translation from screenplay to novel. Another point I admire is that most of the novelization text seems to feature more of Robert Weverka than of Hopkins by a 2 to 1 ratio. Or, it may be that the final film was dramatically cut, leaving screenplay pages on the floor.
I
have never read or viewed A Study in
Terror, but everything I‘ve read about
it indicates that it and Murder By
Decree have similar plots, namely that Jack the Ripper in actuality
was some manifestation of the British government at the time.
Lastly,
I did have one complaint about the novel when compared to the film: whereas James Mason as Watson in the
film was exceptional, and the filmmakers throughout the film clearly went out
of their way to portray Watson as elegant, brave and loyal, in the novelization
Watson is consistently portrayed as a dolt.
Next up: The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Ken Greenwald (1989) - Post 4
Next up: The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Ken Greenwald (1989) - Post 4
Sunday, November 12, 2017
A Taste for Honey by H.F. Heard (1941) - Post 2
“More than 30 years before Nicholas Meyer’s [1974] The Seven-Per-Cent Solution opened the
floodgates of Sherlockian imitation, H.F. Heard’s A Taste for Honey was the first significant book-length Sherlock
Holmes pastiche, and it remains one of the very best.”
A
number of fine books either reference or reprint many of these early adventures:
for example, The Game Is Afoot: Parodies,
Pastiches, and Ponderings of Sherlock Holmes edited by Marvin Kaye; The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
collected and introduced by Richard Lancelyn Green; The Pocket Essential Sherlock Holmes by Mark Campbell; Sherlock Holmes for Dummies by Steven
Doyle and David A. Crowder; Sherlock
Holmes: The Great Detective in Paperback & Pastiche compiled by Gary
Lovisi; and The Big Book of Sherlock
Holmes Stories edited by Otto Penzler.
In other words, the world simply was not prepared to let go of Sherlock Holmes, even though his creator, Arthur Conan Doyle, was no longer writing Holmes stories. Nevertheless, 47 years is a long time and during that period relatively few Holmes stories—invariably short stories—were written and/or published, and they all required permission from the Conan Doyle Estate.
—Jon L. Breen, mystery and
crime-detective writer, scholar and critic (from Blue Dolphin Publishing’s
“Mr.
Mycroft Commemorative Series”)
The year was 1927 and two things of huge import happened to
shake up Sherlock Holmes circles. First, Arthur Conan Doyle’s final Holmes
story was published in Strand Magazine
in its April 1927 issue. Then in May, Conan Doyle’s final Sherlock Holmes book,
The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes was
published. Between 1927 and 1974, a period of 47 years, efforts were made by a
spectrum of people—from scholars to booksellers, from enthusiasts to librarians—to
write Sherlock Holmes short stories in the manner that Arthur Conan Doyle wrote
them, with varying degrees of success.
In
addition, beginning in 1945, Conan Doyle’s son Adrian took up the baton and
crafted a dozen stories, some alone and some as collaborations with noted
mystery writer John Dickson Carr. Then again, August Derleth, prolific
storyteller and publisher of Arkham House books, around the same time asked
permission of the Doyle estate to write Holmes stories and was turned down. Not
one to let a small thing like that deter him, he wrote over the next two
decades some 80 detective stories about Solar Pons as told by Dr. Parker,
obvious clones of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.
In other words, the world simply was not prepared to let go of Sherlock Holmes, even though his creator, Arthur Conan Doyle, was no longer writing Holmes stories. Nevertheless, 47 years is a long time and during that period relatively few Holmes stories—invariably short stories—were written and/or published, and they all required permission from the Conan Doyle Estate.
Enter
in 1941 H.F. Heard, a British writer who was inspired to write a Sherlock
Holmes novel. Whether he sought formal permission to do so or whether he simply
sidestepped that potential obstacle, what resulted was pure magic.
“…but since [Sherlock Holmes] has definitely retired from
London and betaken himself to study bee-farming on the Sussex downs….”
—John H. Watson, M.D.
(Arthur Conan Doyle) in
“The Adventure of the
Second Stain”
What
Heard did was remarkable. First off, he created Sidney Silchester, a prissy
introvert who lived on the Sussex Downs and preferred nothing more than to
enjoy his honey at breakfast and to be left alone. When his honey from his
regular source dried up, he looked about his village for a new source, which quest
brings him into contact with an intense, supremely intelligent older fellow who
raises bees and who has honey to spare. This gentleman identifies himself as
“Mr. Mycroft”.
“’I
have used 'Mycroft'…because my full name was once pretty widely known, and I
wanted, when I retired to be quiet and unmolested…’”
“There!
I have forgotten the name he gave himself. It was something not unlike
Mycroft—Mycroft and then another word, a short one, I think….
’You
see,’ I said, ‘now that I do know your real name, I have to own I have never
heard of you before.’ Then, I must own, he looked amazed….”
—Sidney Silchester
(H.F. Heard) in A Taste for Honey
The
book comprises a sort of journal or memoir in which Sidney Silchester has determined
to write up in chronological order the strange events—perhaps illegal, perhaps
immoral—through which Mr. Mycroft has subjected him, virtually against his
will. Silchester writes in the first person, just as Dr. Watson did. It’s not
long into his narrative that he expresses how frustrated he is, and how taken
aback, by Mr. Mycroft’s peculiar manner of expressing himself, both verbally
and through behavior, and by his chemical experiments. It so happens the reason
Silchester’s honey was no longer available was because the mistress of the beekeeper’s
house was stung to death by her own bees.
In
short order, Mr. Mycroft suspects the poor woman was murdered, and then he
embroils Silchester into his impromptu investigation, not so much because he
cares about the victim, the perpetrator, or even the probable crime itself. No.
Mr. Mycroft is going to all this trouble because it is clear to him that Silchester
was on a very short list to become the next victim, probably followed by
himself. He explains to Silchester that even the simple expediency of moving
out of the town or even out of the country would not deter the murderer’s
obsession to kill him once he decided to do it.
TIP: Be forewarned. Many commentators on this novel and its
two sequels—Reply Paid and The Notched Hairpin—seem to be confused
as to whether ”Mr. Mycroft” is Sherlock Holmes’ brother Mycroft or Holmes
himself. [In fact, in nearly all of these instances, there is no confusion at all; these commentators absolutely and clearly take for granted that Heard's Mycroft IS the brother Mycroft. This is 100% wrong.) These commentators assume, or seem to assume, that Heard, by calling
the character Mycroft, intended for the character to be in fact Mycroft. This
is a sore point for me, since it is crystal clear who it was that retired to
the Sussex Downs to raise bees. And it wasn’t Sherlock’s brother! To make
matters worse, even the publishers of various reprints over the decades of
these books fail to get it right. Thus, rest assured that A Taste for Honey by H.F. Heard and published in 1941, is the first
important novel-length Sherlock Holmes pastiche, throughout which Sherlock
Holmes, himself is front and center.
Next up: Murder by Decree by Robert Weverka from the screenplay by John Hopkins
Next up: Murder by Decree by Robert Weverka from the screenplay by John Hopkins
Thursday, November 9, 2017
The Seven-Per-Cent Solution "edited" by Nicholas Meyer (1974)
In 1974 there was a mighty publishing sea change. Whether it
was the author, Nicholas Meyer, or the publisher, Dutton, I don’t know, but
somebody’s idea minted gold back then and continues to do so. The Seven-Percent-Solution became a huge
bestseller and was the first major modern era Sherlock Holmes pastiche since
the late 1940s when H. F. Heard published the last of his Mr. Mycroft Sherlock
Holmes pastiches.
When The
Seven-Percent-Solution reached a public (who was desperate for a
continuation of Sherlock Holmes, but did not know it yet), the novel included
some innovations that have been replicated thousands of times. Speaking of
which, one estimate of the number of Holmes pastiches to be published in the
intervening 43 years from 1974 is roughly 10,000.
Nicholas Meyer did three unprecedented things in The Seven-Per-Cent Solution that proved
hugely influential:
(1) Either Meyer or his editor supported the use of
pseudo-front matter to increase the over-all verisimilitude of the story. To
underscore that pseudo-reality, Meyer wrote a detailed Foreword (also called a
“framing device”) that explained how the memoir happened to be found and how
Meyer happened to arrange for its publication. This sort of front matter at
root told a story of convoluted mystery and of intertwining fates, detailing
why and how cause and effect, ever patient, ordained that the manuscript would
be hidden, found, resurrected, and/or travel from one location to another. By
its very nature, the existence of this sort of material in a novel is the
epitome of irony. A reader newly approaching the book with no preconceptions
couldn’t help but notice that “somebody” went to a lot of trouble to create a
false provenance that seemed real but clearly was not, being, after all,
affixed to a work featuring well-known clearly fictitious characters. As I
said, unprecedented!
(2) Again, either Meyer or his editor chose to continue that
conceit of verisimilitude by announcing on the book’s cover and also on the
title page that the volume was in actuality “a reprint from the reminiscences
of John H. Watson, M.D. as edited by Nicholas Meyer”, which treats Watson as an
authentic human being and relegates Meyer to the subordinate role of “editor”.
Again, unprecedented!
(3) Probably most importantly, Meyer had Sherlock Holmes and
Dr. Watson cross paths with a true-to-life historical person—Sigmund Freud.
This, too, was unprecedented.
The fallout from these machinations was huge. First off,
Sherlock Holmes novels overnight became a dedicated subgenre with volume after
volume being churned out. Then, at first more often than not, these novels were
filled with various literary apparatus that suggested the legitimate nature of
the volumes. Lastly, again, overnight, writers were falling over themselves to include
in their tales contemporaneous real people of renown, such as Theodore
Roosevelt, Lenin, and Jack the Ripper. Then, of course, it was only a small logical leap to begin
treating famous fictional characters as though were every bit as real as
Roosevelt or Freud. Enter Fu Manchu and H.G. Wells' Martians. Unashamedlyfollowing in the shoes of Meyer, writer Loren D. Estleman did this quite well,utilizing Count Dracula and Dr. Jekyll in two Holmes crossover tales. Finally,
the best of all possible framing devices, to my mind, was Italian scholar Umberto
Eco’s untitled preface to his own giant blockbuster 1980 Sherlockian pastiche, The Name of the Rose.
NEXT: The first ever Holmes pastiche novel.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






